Home › Blogs › Learning blogs › ROE and ROCE
ROE and ROCE explained: how to judge how well a company uses money
Profit tells you how much a company earned. It does not tell you how much money was needed to earn it. Return on equity (ROE) and return on capital employed (ROCE) fill that gap. This guide explains how each is calculated, why they can disagree, and how to read them with a worked example.
Last updated 6 Nov 2026. Sources: standard financial analysis definitions. Written by Vishal Trehan.
SEBI is the Securities and Exchange Board of India. EBIT is earnings before interest and tax. PAT is profit after tax. 1 cr means 1 crore, or 10 million rupees.
Why returns matter more than profit alone
Two companies can both earn ₹120 cr in a year. If one needed ₹800 cr of capital to do it and the other needed ₹4,000 cr, they are very different businesses. The first turns each rupee invested into more profit. Return ratios measure exactly that: profit earned per rupee of money put to work.
ROE: return on equity
ROE measures profit earned on the money that belongs to shareholders.
ROE = profit after tax (PAT) / shareholders’ equity x 100
Shareholders’ equity is share capital plus reserves, the net worth shown on the balance sheet. Many analysts use the average of opening and closing equity for the year. ROE answers one question: for every ₹100 of shareholders’ money, how many rupees of profit did the company make?
ROCE: return on capital employed
ROCE widens the lens to all the money funding the business, from shareholders and lenders.
ROCE = EBIT / capital employed x 100
Capital employed is commonly measured as total assets minus current liabilities, which is roughly equity plus long-term debt. EBIT is used because interest is the lenders’ share of the profit and tax depends on the tax position, so EBIT shows what the operations earned before either is taken out.
A worked example with two fictional companies
Take Company A and Company B. Both earn the same operating profit (EBIT) of ₹160 cr. Assume borrowing costs 10% a year and tax is 25% of profit before tax. They are funded differently:
| Item (₹ cr) | Company A | Company B |
|---|---|---|
| Shareholders’ equity | 800 | 400 |
| Debt | 0 | 600 |
| Capital employed | 800 | 1,000 |
| EBIT | 160 | 160 |
| Interest at 10% | 0 | 60 |
| Profit after tax | 120 | 75 |
| ROE | 15.0% | 18.75% |
| ROCE | 20.0% | 16.0% |
Company B shows the higher ROE (18.75% against 15.0%), yet Company A earns the better return on all capital (20.0% against 16.0%). B’s ROE looks good because it funded 60% of its capital with debt, which shrank the equity base. Debt is not free: B pays ₹60 cr of interest a year whether or not business is good.
What happens when business slows
Now suppose EBIT falls 40% to ₹96 cr for both, with everything else unchanged. Recomputing:
- Company A: PAT falls to ₹72 cr, so ROE is 9.0% and ROCE is 12.0%.
- Company B: interest still takes ₹60 cr, leaving ₹36 cr before tax and ₹27 cr after tax. ROE falls to 6.75% and ROCE to 9.6%.
The leveraged company’s ROE dropped from 18.75% to 6.75%, a fall of 12 percentage points, while the debt-free company’s dropped 6 points. Leverage magnified the gain in the good year and the pain in the weak year. This is why ROE should never be read without looking at debt.
How to read the two ratios together
- ROE well above ROCE usually points to borrowing doing part of the work. Check the debt-to-equity ratio and the interest cover (EBIT divided by interest).
- ROCE and ROE close together suggests the company is funded mostly by equity.
- Compare ROCE with the cost of borrowing. If ROCE is lower than the interest rate the company pays, extra debt is reducing value rather than adding to it.
- Look at several years. One strong year can come from a one-time gain. A steady record through ups and downs says more.
Common distortions to watch for
- Small or negative equity. After years of losses or large buybacks, equity can be tiny, making ROE look huge or meaningless.
- Exceptional items. One-off gains from asset sales inflate PAT without reflecting the core business.
- Cash and investments. A company holding large idle cash has a bigger capital base, which pulls both ratios down even if operations are strong.
- Banks and finance companies. Their debt is their raw material, so ROCE is not meaningful for them. ROE, along with return on assets, is the usual measure.
- Different industries. Compare companies only within similar business models.
Key takeaways
- ROE shows profit per rupee of shareholders’ money; ROCE shows operating profit per rupee of all capital.
- Debt can lift ROE without improving the business, and it magnifies falls when profits drop.
- Read both ratios with debt levels, over several years, and within the same industry.
- A ratio is a starting point for questions, not an answer on its own.
Common questions
What is a good ROE or ROCE?
There is no single number. Capital-heavy businesses such as power or steel often report lower ratios than asset-light businesses such as software. Compare a company with its own past and with similar companies, not with a fixed cut-off.
Why can ROE be high while ROCE is low?
Debt. ROE divides profit by shareholders’ equity only, so borrowing shrinks the denominator and lifts the ratio, even when the business itself earns a modest return on all the capital it uses. ROCE counts debt as capital, so it is not flattered by borrowing.
Is a falling ROE always bad?
Not always. It can fall because the company raised fresh equity, retained large profits that are not yet earning, or paid down debt. Look at why before reading anything into the direction.
Which profit figure is used in ROCE?
Most analysts use earnings before interest and tax (EBIT), the profit before financing costs and tax. Some use operating profit after tax. Whichever is used, apply the same method across companies you compare.
Should I use year-end or average capital?
Averaging the opening and closing figures is common because profit is earned across the year while the balance sheet is a snapshot. A year-end figure is simpler but can distort the ratio after a large fundraise or acquisition.
Is this investment advice?
No. This article is for education. It does not recommend buying, selling or avoiding any security.
Topics: #ROE #ROCE #StockAnalysis #LearnInvesting #StockSelection #StockMarketIndia
Share: WhatsApp · Telegram · X · LinkedIn